I sell software. I recently told two new private equity portfolio companies not to buy any yet. Here’s why.
Two companies, one untapped asset
A middle-market PE firm had just closed two industrial deals. Both investment decisions rested on the same idea: the acquired companies had a large installed base that the previous owners had never made serious efforts to monetize.
The first was an online distributor of metalworking and woodworking machines, such as band saws, shears, and CNC routers priced from $5,000 to $50,000. It had about 80,000 past customers but no CRM, account management, or consumables and parts business. Once a machine shipped, the commercial relationship ended.
The second business sold dust collection equipment and aftermarket parts. Aftermarket was already a meaningful share of revenue, but almost all of it came from inbound inquiries. Customers called when a filter failed. Nobody from the company called them first.
Both sales teams had five people. Both teams focused on taking orders, and the reps chased new project sales because that was what their comp plans rewarded.
Why I led with people, not software
The obvious move was to buy a platform, load the data and start automating. My advice was the opposite: put one dedicated person on it, give them a spreadsheet and a simple process, and learn what works and what breaks.
After 35 years in this business, I’ve seen that data and software are usually the easy part. Most failures I’ve seen came from people and process. If nobody owns the outreach and nobody has designed the cadence, automation just makes the gaps run faster.
One of the operators framed it well from the owner’s side. Software has a cost, and the question is when it pays back. If the organization isn’t ready to use it, the payback date may never come.
Five lessons for PE-owned industrials
Across dozens of implementations, I’ve seen the same problems and identified the same lessons.
- Companies must climb the maturity curve systematically. Most companies start out reactively, taking orders and nothing more. The next step is a dedicated owner for aftermarket sales, then real inside-sales efforts that turn aftermarket into a profit center, and then quota-carrying reps. Technology pays off once each of those steps has been taken, not before.
- Automate the long tail, and keep humans on the big accounts. A replacement band saw blade doesn’t need a salesperson. Consumables, parts reminders, and replenishment programs can run on automation. With 80,000 customers, they have to. Capital purchases need a person. Those buyers ask highly specific questions and expect customized attention. A bot likely can’t do either.
- Use a hybrid hand-off. A packaging equipment OEM we work with has account managers covering its top 1,000 customers. Automation covers the next 3,000, with AI-driven emails and follow-ups. When an account shows enough business potential, AI flags it as a serious revenue opportunity, and responsibility transfers to a human.
- Some of your data is (probably) clean enough. Nearly every company I’ve worked with has messy installed base data. Even so, work orders, service records, and order history usually hold enough information to build a useful picture. AI now also lets us bring unstructured data into that picture, which adds dimension and specificity.
- Remember that the PE clock is running. Every month of delay is deferred revenue and margin, which means lost valuation at exit. The critical window is the first two to three years of the hold. That’s why you start now with a person and a spreadsheet instead of waiting for the perfect system and pristine data. Those two things may never come.
Why can’t AI solve the problem on its own?
If bots can do much of the work on most of the accounts, does the maturity curve still apply? For low-value consumables, AI may let a company skip a hire. However, it cannot eliminate the need for a clear point of view on whom to target, data clean enough to drive the outreach, and someone who checks that the automation is working and tackles the questions AI cannot or should not answer on its own. People, process, and technology must work together. AI enhances the role of technology only when the necessary foundation is in place.
If you’d like to discuss your aftermarket opportunities and the right process for capturing their value, request a consultation with an expert now.




